After a few weeks of work on my new framework for multidocument interfaces called BrekiViews (yes, I know I promised to write a little about it, but I just didn’t have enough time and concentration to put the brainstorms in my head into some coherent words) and refactoring Kosmos code to use it, I’m finally able to show some basic stuff in the new Kosmos GUI application. It’s all pretty simple at the moment, I got just one menu item working: File | Open Project. But I wanted to use this opportunity and start using White from ThoughtWorks to write automated GUI tests, since I was looking forward to trying the White out.
Documentation (Or The Lack Of It)
Unfortunately, the first impressions aren’t that good. The worst problem is lack of documentation. There are some pages written on the project’s CodePlex page and I also stumbled on a few posts which have some more examples on how to use it, but in general the API is undocumented. NDoc documentation that comes in the latest release just contains the API reference, without any human-generated documentation. It even states that it’s based on .NET Framework 1.1, which was obviously autogenerated and is probably wrong, since the API includes generics. I haven’t checked the source code directly though, maybe there is something there.
Yes I know, it’s an open source project and I shouldn’t expect too much, but I still think that such a project for which the whole purpose is to be used through an API should contain at least some documentation. Otherwise you spend a lot of time experimenting with the API to achieve the results.
Keyboard Problems
Like most other UI testing frameworks, White too suffers from quirks. I wanted to start the “Open Project” menu action using the keyboard shortcut, so I tried with:
mainWindow.Keyboard.HoldKey (KeyboardInput.SpecialKeys.CONTROL);
mainWindow.Keyboard.Enter ("o");
Which ended up forcing me to restart the computer, since the OS started acting very funny, as if the Ctrl key was still being pressed. I guess I should have added
mainWindow.Keyboard.LeaveKey (KeyboardInput.SpecialKeys.CONTROL);
to unpress the Ctrl key, but I’m not sure, since I couldn’t find any documentation on using the keyboard in White. Anyway, a helper method that would accept a shortcut as a string (something like KeyboardInput.Press (”Ctrl+O”) would be very helpful).
Clicking The Menus
After abandoning the keyboard approach, I tried to start “Open Project” by clicking on the menu item. I did some experimenting and finally managed to write a basic test, here’s the whole test fixture:
[TestFixture
]
public class BasicTests
{
[Test
]
public void OpenProject
()
{
Menu fileMenu = mainWindow.
MenuBar.
MenuItem ("File");
fileMenu.
Click();
Menu openProjectMenu = fileMenu.
SubMenu ("Open Project…");
openProjectMenu.
Click();
}
[SetUp]
public void Setup()
{
application = Application.Launch (@”..\..\..\Kosmos.Gui\bin\Debug\Kosmos.Gui.exe");
mainWindow = application.GetWindow ("Kosmos GUI", InitializeOption.NoCache);
Assert.IsNotNull(mainWindow);
Assert.IsTrue (mainWindow.DisplayState == DisplayState.Restored);
}
[TearDown]
public void Teardown()
{
application.Kill();
}
private Application application;
private Window mainWindow;
}
White Facade
From my experience with other UI testing frameworks, if you intend to do more than a few simple UI tests it is a good idea to create some sort of a facade around the testing API. This way you simplify the interface to common use cases you typically use and eliminate any nasty quirks (like memory or resource leaks). Bil Simser has done something to that affect for White, although I don’t support his views on (not) using Setup and Teardown methods in unit tests.
Even better: why not implement a fluent inteface facade? Something like
WhiteFacade.Run(kosmosGuiPath).Press ("Ctrl+O")
or
WhiteFacade.Run(kosmosGuiPath).ClickMenu ("File", "Open Project…")
would be much nicer than the above code, don’t you think? Okey, I’m oversimplifying, I know :), but I will try to do something in the direction of a fluent interface facade, since I don’t intend to abandon the White just yet.
